Modern Physics · Advanced Topics

Topological Phases of Matter

Topology — the mathematics of shapes and connectivity — enters condensed matter physics in a profound way. Topological insulators, the quantum Hall effect, and topological superconductors host protected surface states and exotic quasiparticles that cannot be removed by any smooth perturbation.

PrerequisitesSolid-state physics (Ch. SS) · Quantum mechanics (Ch. 22) · Group theory (Ch. GT) · Linear algebra (Ch. LA)
Learning Goals
  • Define the Berry phase and Berry curvature and compute them for a spin-1/2 in a rotating magnetic field.
  • Derive the TKNN formula relating Hall conductance to the first Chern number of filled Bloch bands.
  • Classify 1D topological phases using the SSH model winding number and identify protected edge states.
  • Explain how time-reversal symmetry gives rise to the Z2Z_{2} invariant and spin-momentum-locked surface states in 3D topological insulators.
  • Describe Majorana bound states in the Kitaev chain and their potential role in topological quantum computation.

TP.1 Topology in Quantum Mechanics

In band theory, the electronic states at each crystal momentum k form a Hilbert space. As k traverses the Brillouin zone (a torus TdT^d in d dimensions), the occupied bands define a vector bundle — and vector bundles are classified by topological invariants.

The key invariant: the Berry phase. As k evolves slowly around a loop in the Brillouin zone, the eigenstate ∣uk⟩|u_k\rangle acquires a geometric phase:

γ=i∮⟨uk∣∇k∣uk⟩⋅dk(Berry phase around a loop in k-space)\gamma = i \oint \langle u_k|\nabla_k|u_k\rangle \cdot d\mathbf{k} \qquad \text{(Berry phase around a loop in } k\text{-space)}(TP.1)

The integrand Ak=i⟨uk∣∇k∣uk⟩\mathbf{A}_k = i\langle u_k|\nabla_k|u_k\rangle is the Berry connection (analogous to the vector potential A in electromagnetism). The associated curvature is theBerry curvature: Ωk=∇k×Ak\boldsymbol{\Omega}_k = \nabla_k \times \mathbf{A}_k (analogous to the magnetic field B).

TP.2 The Quantum Hall Effect and Chern Numbers

In a 2D electron gas under strong perpendicular magnetic field B, the Hall conductance is quantized with extraordinary precision:

σxy=ν e2h(integer quantum Hall effect, IQHE)\sigma_{xy} = \nu\,\frac{e^2}{h} \qquad \text{(integer quantum Hall effect, IQHE)}(TP.2)

where ν = 1, 2, 3, ... is an integer. The quantization is exact — better than 1 part in 10⁹ — independent of sample size, purity, or microscopic details. This robustness is topological in origin.

Theorem TP.1 — TKNN Formula — Chern Number
Thouless, Kohmoto, Nightingale, den Nijs (1982): the Hall conductance of a filled band is given by the first Chern number C1C_{1}:σxy=C1e2hC1=12π∫BZΩk d2k∈Z\sigma_{xy} = C_1 \frac{e^2}{h} \qquad C_1 = \frac{1}{2\pi} \int_{\text{BZ}} \Omega_k \, d^2k \in \mathbb{Z}The Chern number C1C_{1} is a topological invariant — it cannot change without closing the band gap. A sample with C1=1C_{1} = 1 and a vacuum with C1=0C_{1} = 0 must have a topological interface — a gapless edge state that conducts without dissipation. This is the quantum Hall edge channel.

The fractional quantum Hall effect (ν = 1/3, 2/5, ...) requires strongly correlated states — Laughlin wavefunctions — beyond simple band theory. The elementary excitations carry fractional charge e/3 (Nobel 1998 to Laughlin, Störmer, Tsui). These anyons (with fractional statistics) are candidates for topological quantum computing.

TP.3 Time-Reversal Invariant Topological Insulators

Without a magnetic field, time-reversal symmetry T² = −1 (for spin-½ particles) allows a different topological invariant — the ℤ₂ invariant ν ∈ {0, 1}.

ν = 0: ordinary insulator. ν = 1: topological insulator (TI). The TI has a bulk band gap but gapless surface states — protected by time-reversal symmetry. These surface states cannot be gapped without breaking time-reversal or closing the bulk gap.

Key feature: spin-momentum locking. The surface Dirac cone has spin perpendicular to momentum — spin up goes right, spin down goes left. Backscattering (k → −k) requires flipping spin, which is forbidden by time-reversal. This makes the surface states immune to non-magnetic disorder.

First 2D TI: HgTe quantum wells (König et al., 2007, Science). First 3D TI: Bi₁₋ₓSbₓ (Hsieh et al., 2008); the simplest is Bi₂Se₃ (Xia et al., 2009) — metallic Dirac cone on the surface, insulating bulk. ARPES directly images the Dirac cone surface state.

Example TP.1 — SSH Model — 1D Topological Insulator

The Su-Schrieffer-Heeger (SSH) model: 1D chain with alternating hopping t1t_{1} (intracell) and t2t_{2} (intercell). Find the bulk invariant and edge states.

Bloch Hamiltonian:H(k)=(t1+t2cos⁡k)σx+t2sin⁡kσy(2×2H(k) = (t_{1} + t_{2} \cos k)\sigma_{x} + t_{2} \sin k \sigma_{y} (2\times 2 matrix, two sites per unit cell). Eigenvalues: E=±(t1+t2cos⁡k)2+t22sin⁡2kE = \pm\sqrt{(t_{1}+t_{2}\cos k)^{2} + t_{2}^{2}\sin^{2}k}.
Gap condition:Gap closes at k=0:t1+t2=0→∣t1∣=t2k = 0: t_{1} + t_{2} = 0 \to |t_{1}| = t_{2}. Gap closes at k=π:t1−t2=0→t1=t2k = \pi: t_{1} - t_{2} = 0 \to t_{1} = t_{2}. Phase transition at |t1∣=∣t2∣t_{1}| = |t_{2}|.
Winding number:The Hamiltonian H(k)=d(k)⋅σH(k) = d(k)\cdot\sigma. Ask:0→2π,d(k)=(t1+t2cos⁡k,t2sin⁡k)As k: 0 \to 2\pi, d(k) = (t_{1}+t_{2}\cos k, t_{2}\sin k) traces a circle. Winding number W = number of times it winds around origin. W=0W = 0 for t1>t2t_{1} > t_{2} (trivial); W=1W = 1 for t1<t2t_{1} < t_{2} (topological).
Edge states:Topological phase (t2>t1t_{2} > t_{1}): semi-infinite chain has zero-energy edge state localized at the boundary, with wavefunction decaying as (t1/t2)nt_{1}/t_{2})^{n}. Two edge states at opposite ends — robust to perturbations that preserve chiral symmetry.
Physical realization:Polyacetylene (CH)nCH)_{n} in dimerized (Peierls) phase — the SSH model. Soliton defects carry charge e/2 (fractionalization). Modern realizations: photonic lattices, ultracold atoms, acoustic metamaterials.

TP.4 Topological Superconductors and Majorana Fermions

A topological superconductor has a superconducting bulk gap but hosts Majorana bound states at its boundaries. Majorana fermions are their own antiparticle: γ† = γ. They obey non-Abelian statistics.

The Kitaev chainmodel: 1D chain of spinless fermions with p-wave pairing Δ. Topological phase for |μ| < 2t. Majorana modes at each end: γ₁ = c₁ + c₁†, γ2=i(cN−cN†)\gamma_2 = i(c_N - c_N^\dagger). The two Majoranas form a zero-energy non-local fermion c = (γ₁ + iγ₂)/2 — the ground state is degenerate (two-fold: c|0⟩ and |0⟩).

Non-Abelian anyons: exchanging two Majoranas performs a unitary rotation in the degenerate ground state subspace. This rotation depends on the order of exchanges — non-commuting, hence non-Abelian. Topological quantum computation: encode qubits in Majorana pairs; gates implemented by braiding. Errors require exciting quasiparticles across the gap — exponentially suppressed.

Experimental candidates: semiconductor nanowires (InAs, InSb) with strong spin-orbit coupling, proximity-coupled to s-wave superconductors and in a magnetic field. Zero-bias conductance peak signatures observed but not yet conclusively proven to be Majorana (2012–2024). Recent Microsoft experiments (2023) show promising signatures.

TP.5 Weyl Semimetals

A Weyl semimetal is a 3D material with band crossings (Weyl points) in the bulk. Near each crossing, the Hamiltonian:

H(k)=±vF (k⋅σ)(Weyl Hamiltonian, ±=chirality)H(\mathbf{k}) = \pm v_F\, (\mathbf{k} \cdot \boldsymbol{\sigma}) \qquad \text{(Weyl Hamiltonian, } \pm = \text{chirality)}(TP.3)

Weyl points act as monopoles of Berry curvature in k-space — they come in pairs of opposite chirality (Nielsen-Ninomiya theorem) and cannot be annihilated individually. On the surface, Weyl points project onto arcs — Fermi arcs — open contours connecting projections of Weyl points of opposite chirality.

The chiral anomaly: in a parallel E and B field, charge is pumped between Weyl nodes of opposite chirality → negative magnetoresistance. First observed in TaAs (2015). Weyl semimetals are 3D analogues of graphene's Dirac points, but topologically protected in 3D.

Definition TP.1 — Common Traps
  • Topology is global: local perturbations cannot change an invariant without closing a gap.
  • Edge states depend on bulk topology: they are not ordinary surface defects.
  • Berry phase is gauge-sensitive but observables are not: invariants remove arbitrary phase choices.
  • Protection has limits: disorder or interactions that break required symmetries can destroy a phase.
Exercises — TP.1–TP.5 Topological Phases
1.
Calculate the Berry phase for a spin-½ particle when its quantization axis traces a closed loop of solid angle Ω on the Bloch sphere. What is the result for an equatorial loop?
radians
Straightforward
2.Compute the Chern number for the 2D massive Dirac Hamiltonian H=vF(kxσx+kyσy)+mσzH = v_{F}(k_{x} \sigma_{x} + k_{y} \sigma_{y}) + m \sigma_{z}. Show it changes at m=0m = 0.
Intermediate
3.
Derive the Landau level spectrum in a perpendicular magnetic field. What is the degeneracy per level? At what temperature does the IQHE occur for GaAs(m∗=0.07me)GaAs (m* = 0.07m_{e}) in B=10TB = 10 T?
eV
Intermediate
4.Describe the tenfold way classification of topological insulators and superconductors. What symmetry classes govern 3D topological insulators and 1D topological superconductors?
Challenging
Key Takeaways
  • Berry phase γ=i∮⟨u∣∇k∣u⟩⋅dk\gamma = i\oint⟨u|\nabla_{k}|u⟩\cdot dk: geometric phase from adiabatic evolution in parameter space.
  • Chern number C1=(1/2π)∫Ωkd2k∈ZC_{1} = (1/2\pi)\int\Omega_{k} d^{2}k ∈ ℤ. Hall conductance σxy=C1e2/h(TKNN)\sigma_{xy} = C_{1} e^{2}/h (TKNN).
  • Topological insulators: ℤ₂ invariant from T2=−1T^{2}=-1. Gapless Dirac surface states, spin-momentum locking.
  • SSH model: winding number W=0W=0 (trivial) or W=1W=1 (topological). Edge zero modes in topological phase.
  • Majorana fermions (γ†=γ\gamma^\dagger=\gamma): at ends of Kitaev chain. Non-Abelian statistics → topological qubits.
  • Tenfold way: 10 symmetry classes × dimension → periodic table of topological phases.