Modern Physics · Advanced Topics

Neutrino Physics & Flavor Oscillations

Neutrinos are the most abundant matter particles in the universe yet barely interact. The discovery that they oscillate between flavors — and hence have mass — is the first confirmed physics beyond the Standard Model. Neutrino physics touches on nuclear reactions, cosmology, CP violation, and Majorana fermions.

PrerequisitesParticle physics (Ch. PP) · Quantum mechanics (Ch. 22) · Nuclear physics (Ch. N) · Special relativity (Ch. 21)
Learning Goals
  • Apply the two-flavor oscillation formula P(να→νβ)=sin⁡2(2θ)sin⁡2(Δm2L/4E)P(\nu_\alpha\to\nu_\beta) = \sin^{2}(2\theta)\sin^{2}(\Delta m^{2}L/4E) to solar and atmospheric data.
  • Derive the MSW resonance condition and identify the electron density at which it occurs inside the Sun.
  • Explain the seesaw mechanism and compute the required MRM_{R} to generate a light neutrino mass of 0.05 eV.
  • Describe neutrinoless double beta decay and what its observation would prove about neutrino nature.
  • Distinguish Dirac and Majorana mass terms and outline how leptogenesis connects neutrino masses to the baryon asymmetry.

NU.1 Neutrinos in the Standard Model (and Beyond)

The SM has three massless left-handed neutrinos: νe,νμ,ντ\nu_e, \nu_\mu, \nu_\tau (one per lepton family). Neutrinos interact only via the weak force (W±, Z) — cross sectionσ∼GF2s/π≈10−45 cm2\sigma \sim G_F^2 s/\pi \approx 10^{-45}\ \text{cm}^2 at 1 MeV (10⁷ times smaller than electromagnetic). Mean free path in water: λ=1/(nσ)∼1018 km\lambda = 1/(n\sigma) \sim 10^{18}\ \text{km} — the Earth is transparent to low-energy neutrinos.

Solar neutrino problem (1968–2001): the Davis chlorine detector measured only 1/3 of the neutrino flux predicted by the Standard Solar Model. Resolution: electron neutrinos produced in the Sun oscillate to other flavors on their way to Earth — and the Davis detector was only sensitive to νe\nu_e. Confirmed by SNO (2001): total flux of all flavors = predicted solar model flux. Nobel Prize 2015 to McDonald (SNO) and Kajita (Super-Kamiokande).

NU.2 Neutrino Oscillations

If neutrino mass eigenstates |ν₁⟩, |ν₂⟩, |ν₃⟩ differ from flavor eigenstates∣νe⟩,∣νμ⟩,∣ντ⟩|\nu_e\rangle, |\nu_\mu\rangle, |\nu_\tau\rangle, mixing occurs via the PMNS matrix U:

∣να⟩=∑iUαi∗ ∣νi⟩(PMNS mixing, α=e,μ,τ; i=1,2,3)|\nu_\alpha\rangle = \sum_i U^*_{\alpha i}\, |\nu_i\rangle \qquad \text{(PMNS mixing, } \alpha = e, \mu, \tau;\ i = 1, 2, 3\text{)}(NU.1)

For two-flavor mixing: U=(cos⁡θsin⁡θ−sin⁡θcos⁡θ)U = \begin{pmatrix} \cos\theta & \sin\theta \\ -\sin\theta & \cos\theta \end{pmatrix}. A να\nu_\alpha produced at t=0 evolves in time. The probability of finding νβ\nu_\beta at time t:

P(να→νβ)=sin⁡2(2θ) sin⁡2 ⁣(Δm2L4E)(oscillation formula, L=distance, E=energy)P(\nu_\alpha \to \nu_\beta) = \sin^2(2\theta)\, \sin^2\!\left(\frac{\Delta m^2 L}{4E}\right) \qquad \text{(oscillation formula, } L = \text{distance, } E = \text{energy)}(NU.2)

where Δm² = m₂² − m₁² in eV². The oscillation length: Losc=4πE/Δm2=2.48 km×E[GeV]/Δm2[eV2]L_{\text{osc}} = 4\pi E/\Delta m^2 = 2.48\ \text{km} \times E[\text{GeV}]/\Delta m^2[\text{eV}^2].

Theorem NU.1 — MSW Effect
In matter, the effective potential for νe\nu_{e} differs from νμ,τ\nu_\mu,\tau due to coherent forward scattering: VCC=2GFneV_{CC} = \sqrt 2 G_{F} n_{e} (charged current), VNC=−GFnn/2V_{NC} = -G_{F} n_{n}/\sqrt 2. The effective Hamiltonian in the flavor basis:Heff=Δm24E(−cos⁡2θ+Asin⁡2θsin⁡2θcos⁡2θ−A)H_{\text{eff}} = \frac{\Delta m^2}{4E}\begin{pmatrix} -\cos 2\theta + A & \sin 2\theta \\ \sin 2\theta & \cos 2\theta - A \end{pmatrix}where A=22GFneE/Δm2A = 2\sqrt 2 G_{F} n_{e} E / \Delta m^{2}. Resonance condition A=cos⁡2θA = \cos2\theta: maximal mixing even for small vacuum θ. This MSW (Mikheyev-Smirnov-Wolfenstein) effect explains why solar νe\nu_{e} are converted to νμ/ντ\nu_\mu/\nu_\tau inside the Sun.
Example NU.1 — Atmospheric Neutrino Oscillation at Super-Kamiokande

Super-Kamiokande (1998) observed a deficit of upward-going νμvs\nu_\mu vs. downward-going νμ\nu_\mu (from cosmic ray interactions). Use the two-flavor formula to find Δm2\Delta m^{2} and θ.

Setup:Cosmic ray pions decay: π→μ+νμ,μ→e+νe+νμ\pi \to \mu + \nu_\mu, \mu \to e + \nu_{e} + \nu_\mu. Expected ratio R=νμ/νe≈2R = \nu_\mu/\nu_{e} \approx 2. Observed: R was lower and strongly L-dependent (upward = longer path through Earth, L ~ 10,000 km vs. downward L 15km).νeL ~ 15 km). \nu_{e} shows no deficit; νμ\nu_\mu shows strong deficit for upward-going — νμ\nu_\mu oscillating to ντ(ντ\nu_\tau (\nu_\tau undetected at Super-K at that energy).
L/E analysis:Plot survival probability P(νμ→νμ)=1−sin⁡2(2θ)sin⁡2(1.27Δm2[eV2]L[km]/E[GeV])vsL/EP(\nu_\mu \to \nu_\mu) = 1 - \sin^{2}(2\theta)\sin^{2}(1.27 \Delta m^{2}[eV^{2}] L[km]/E[GeV]) vs L/E. SK data: dip at L/E ~ 500 km/GeV. Pmin≈0P_{\text{min}} \approx 0: maximal mixing sin⁡2(2θ)≈1→θ≈45°\sin^{2}(2\theta) \approx 1 \to \theta \approx 45°.
Mass squared difference:At minimum: 1.27Δm2×500=π/2→Δm2=π/(2×1.27×500)≈2.5×10−3eV21.27 \Delta m^{2} \times 500 = \pi/2 \to \Delta m^{2} = \pi/(2 \times 1.27 \times 500) \approx 2.5\times 10^{-3} eV^{2}. More precisely from fit: Δm2(23)≈2.4×10−3eV2,sin⁡2(2θ23)>0.99\Delta m^{2}(23) \approx 2.4\times 10^{-3} eV^{2}, \sin^{2}(2\theta_{23}) > 0.99 (nearly maximal). Normal ordering: m3>m2>m1m_{3} > m_{2} > m_{1}; inverted: m3<m1<m2m_{3} < m_{1} < m_{2}.
Implications:Δm2(23)=2.4×10−3eV2\Delta m^{2}(23) = 2.4\times 10^{-3} eV^{2} implies m3≥Δm2≈0.05eVm_{3} \ge \sqrt\Delta m^{2} \approx 0.05 eV (at least one mass eigenstate ≥50meV\ge 50 meV). Solar mixing: Δm2(12)=7.5×10−5eV2,θ12≈34°\Delta m^{2}(12) = 7.5\times 10^{-5} eV^{2}, \theta_{12} \approx 34°. Absolute masses unknown; upper bound from cosmology: ∑mν<0.12eV\sum m_\nu < 0.12 eV (Planck 2018). KATRIN experiment: m(νe)<0.45eVm(\nu_{e}) < 0.45 eV directly.

NU.3 Neutrino Mass Mechanisms

The SM gives massless neutrinos (no right-handed component). To add mass:

Dirac mass: add right-handed νR\nu_R (sterile). Yukawa coupling y: mD=yv/2m_D = yv/\sqrt{2}(v = Higgs VEV = 246 GeV). To get mν∼0.1m_\nu \sim 0.1 eV: y ~ 4×10⁻¹³ — unnaturally small.

Majorana mass: if ν = ν̄ (its own antiparticle). Forbidden for charged particles (charge conservation). Allowed for neutral neutrinos. Majorana mass term: mM νcνm_M\, \nu^c \nu (Lorentz invariant for neutral fermion).

mν∼mD2MR(seesaw type I: heavy MR→naturally light mν)m_\nu \sim \frac{m_D^2}{M_R} \qquad \text{(seesaw type I: heavy } M_R \to \text{naturally light } m_\nu\text{)}(NU.3)

The seesaw mechanism: a heavy right-handed Majorana neutrino (mass MR∼1015M_R \sim 10^{15} GeV, GUT scale) generates naturally light left-handed neutrinos. Baryogenesis via leptogenesis: CP-violating decay of heavy NRN_R in early universe → lepton asymmetry → converted to baryon asymmetry via sphaleron processes.

Neutrinoless double beta decay (0νββ): N → N+2 + 2e⁻ (no neutrinos). Only possible if ν is Majorana. Half-life: T1/2≥1026T_{1/2} \ge 10^{26} yr (KamLAND-Zen). Discovery would confirm Majorana nature and measure ∣mββ∣=∣∑iUei2mi∣|m_{\beta\beta}| = \left|\sum_i U_{ei}^2 m_i\right|.

NU.4 Neutrino Sources and Detectors

Solar neutrinos: pp chain dominates (pp→d+e++νepp \to d + e^+ + \nu_e, E < 0.42 MeV); ⁸B neutrinos (E ~ 14 MeV) detected by SNO. Total flux: ~6×10¹⁰ cm⁻²s⁻¹.Reactor antineutrinos (νˉe\bar\nu_e): from β-decay of fission products. KamLAND: 180 km average baseline, measured θ₁₂ and Δm122\Delta m^2_{12}. Daya Bay, RENO: short baseline (1-2 km), measured θ₁₃ = 8.5° (2012).

IceCube: cubic-kilometer detector at South Pole. Cherenkov light from ν interactions. TeV-PeV astrophysical neutrinos detected (2013): diffuse flux consistent with E−2.5E^{-2.5} spectrum. First sources: Seyfert galaxy NGC 1068 (2022), blazar TXS 0506+056.DUNE: long-baseline experiment (Fermilab to Homestake, 1300 km). Goals: CP violation in neutrino sector (δCP\delta_{CP}), mass ordering, proton decay.

Definition NU.1 — Common Traps
  • Flavor states are not mass states: oscillations happen because propagation phases differ.
  • Oscillation needs nonzero mass differences: absolute mass scale is a separate question.
  • Matter changes mixing: the MSW effect can enhance flavor conversion.
  • Neutrinos are hard to detect because weak interactions are weak: huge fluxes still produce few events.
Exercises — NU.1–NU.4 Neutrino Physics
1.
Calculate the νe\nu_{e} survival probability for solar 8B^{8}B neutrinos (E=10MeV,L=1.5×108kmE = 10 MeV, L = 1.5\times 10^{8} km) using two-flavor vacuum oscillation with Δm2(12)=7.5×10−5eV2\Delta m^{2}(12) = 7.5\times 10^{-5} eV^{2} and sin⁡2(2θ)=0.855\sin^{2}(2\theta) = 0.855.
Straightforward
2.
Derive the MSW resonance condition in matter. At what electron density does resonance occur for 8B^{8}B solar neutrinos (E=10MeVE = 10 MeV)? Is this density present in the Sun?
cm⁻³
Intermediate
3.Explain the type-I seesaw mechanism. What right-handed neutrino mass MRM_{R} is needed to generate mν 0.05eVm_\nu ~ 0.05 eV with Dirac mass mD mτm_{D} ~ m_\tau? Outline how leptogenesis generates the baryon asymmetry.
Intermediate
4.Explain neutrinoless double beta decay. What is the effective Majorana mass mββm_\beta\beta? What do current experimental bounds (KamLAND−Zen:T12>2.3×1026yrKamLAND-Zen: T\frac{1}{2} > 2.3\times 10^{26} yr) imply for the neutrino mass hierarchy?
Challenging
Key Takeaways
  • Neutrino oscillations: P(να→νβ)=sin⁡2(2θ)sin⁡2(1.267Δm2L/E)P(\nu_\alpha\to\nu_\beta) = \sin^{2}(2\theta)\sin^{2}(1.267 \Delta m^{2} L/E). Require nonzero masses →BSM\to BSM physics.
  • Atmospheric: Δm2(23)≈2.4×10−3eV2,θ23≈45°\Delta m^{2}(23) \approx 2.4\times 10^{-3} eV^{2}, \theta_{23} \approx 45°. Solar: Δm2(12)=7.5×10−5eV2,θ12=34°.θ13=8.5°\Delta m^{2}(12) = 7.5\times 10^{-5} eV^{2}, \theta_{12} = 34°. \theta_{13} = 8.5°.
  • MSW effect: matter potential for νe\nu_{e} from W exchange. Resonance A=cos⁡2θA=\cos2\theta → level crossing → adiabatic conversion.
  • Seesaw: mν=mD2/MRm_\nu = m_{D}^{2}/M_{R}. GUT-scale MR 1015GeVM_{R} ~ 10^{15} GeV gives naturally mν 0.1eVm_\nu ~ 0.1 eV.
  • Majorana vs Dirac: neutrinoless double beta decay tests Majorana nature. Current: T12>1026yr→mββ<36−156meVT\frac{1}{2} > 10^{26} yr \to m_\beta\beta < 36-156 meV.
  • Absolute masses: cosmological bound ∑mν<0.12eV\sum m_\nu < 0.12 eV (Planck). KATRIN direct: m(νe)<0.45eVm(\nu_{e}) < 0.45 eV.