Modern Physics · Advanced Topics

Many-Body Quantum Physics

Interacting quantum systems of many particles exhibit emergent phenomena — superconductivity, the Mott transition, the fractional quantum Hall effect — that cannot be understood from single-particle physics. Second quantization, Green's functions, and diagrammatic methods are the essential tools.

PrerequisitesQuantum mechanics (Ch. 22) · Statistical mechanics (Ch. S) · Solid-state physics (Ch. SS) · Quantum field theory (Ch. QFT)
Learning Goals
  • Write the electron-electron Coulomb interaction in second-quantized form and identify Hartree and Fock contributions.
  • Derive the RPA dielectric function and the Thomas-Fermi screening length from the static Lindhard function.
  • Explain the Hubbard model and the Mott insulator transition in terms of U/t ratio.
  • Interpret the spectral function A(k,ω)A(k,\omega) and the quasiparticle weight ZkZ_{k} in Fermi liquid theory.
  • State the Laughlin wavefunction for filling ν=1/m\nu = 1/m and explain fractional charge using the plasma analogy.

MB.1 Second Quantization

For N identical particles, the Fock space formalism is more natural than first quantization. Creation and annihilation operators:

Bosons: [bk,bk′†]=δkk′[b_k, b^\dagger_{k'}] = \delta_{kk'}, [bk,bk′]=0[b_k, b_{k'}] = 0.Fermions: {ck,ck′†}=δkk′\{c_k, c^\dagger_{k'}\} = \delta_{kk'}, {ck,ck′}=0\{c_k, c_{k'}\} = 0 (anticommutators). The Pauli exclusion principle is automatic: (ck†)2=0(c^\dagger_k)^2 = 0(can't create two fermions in same state).

The Hamiltonian in second quantization:

H=∑kσεkckσ†ckσ+12∑k,k′,q,σ,σ′Vq ck+q,σ†ck′−q,σ′†ck′,σ′ck,σH = \sum_{k\sigma} \varepsilon_k c^\dagger_{k\sigma} c_{k\sigma} + \frac{1}{2}\sum_{k,k',q,\sigma,\sigma'} V_q\, c^\dagger_{k+q,\sigma} c^\dagger_{k'-q,\sigma'} c_{k',\sigma'} c_{k,\sigma}(MB.1)

The first term is kinetic energy; the second is the two-body interaction in momentum space. For the Coulomb interaction Vq=e2/(ε0q2)V_q = e^2/(\varepsilon_0 q^2) in 3D.

MB.2 Hartree-Fock Theory

The simplest variational ansatz: a Slater determinant ∣ΦHF⟩=∏k∈occck†∣0⟩|\Phi_{\text{HF}}\rangle = \prod_{k \in \text{occ}} c^\dagger_k |0\rangle. Variation gives the Hartree-Fock equations:

[−ℏ2∇22m+VH(r)+VX]ψk(r)=εkψk(r)\left[-\frac{\hbar^2\nabla^2}{2m} + V_H(\mathbf{r}) + V_X\right]\psi_k(\mathbf{r}) = \varepsilon_k \psi_k(\mathbf{r})(MB.2)

where VH=∫n(r′) e24πε0∣r−r′∣ d3r′V_H = \int n(\mathbf{r}')\, \frac{e^2}{4\pi\varepsilon_0|\mathbf{r} - \mathbf{r}'|}\, d^3r' (Hartree, electrostatic) and VXV_X is the non-local Fock exchange operator. For the homogeneous electron gas: exchange energy per electron EX/N=−32π(9π4)1/3rs−1≈−0.916/rsE_X/N = -\frac{3}{2\pi}\left(\frac{9\pi}{4}\right)^{1/3} r_s^{-1} \approx -0.916/r_s (in Rydberg units), where rs=(3/(4πn))1/3/a0r_s = (3/(4\pi n))^{1/3}/a_0 is the Wigner-Seitz radius in units of the Bohr radius.

Definition MB.1 — Hubbard Model
The single-band Hubbard model captures the competition between kinetic energy (hopping t) and on-site Coulomb repulsion (U):H=−t∑⟨ij⟩,σciσ†cjσ+U∑ini↑ni↓AtU): H = -t \sum_{⟨ij⟩,\sigma} c^\dagger_{i\sigma} c_{j\sigma} + U \sum_{i} n_{i↑} n_{i↓} At half-filling (one electron per site): for U/t ≫ 1, hopping is suppressed → Mott insulator. For U/t ≪ 1: metallic (Fermi liquid). The Mott transition at intermediate U/t is a paradigmatic strongly correlated problem — not captured by HF.

MB.3 Green's Functions and Self-Energy

The single-particle Green's function encodes excitation properties:

G(k,ω)=1ω−εk−Σ(k,ω)+iη(Dyson equation: G=G0+G0ΣG)G(k, \omega) = \frac{1}{\omega - \varepsilon_k - \Sigma(k,\omega) + i\eta} \qquad \text{(Dyson equation: } G = G_0 + G_0 \Sigma G\text{)}(MB.3)

The self-energy Σ(k, ω) encodes all interaction effects. The spectral function A(k,ω)=−1π Im G(k,ω+iη)A(k, \omega) = -\frac{1}{\pi}\,\text{Im}\, G(k, \omega + i\eta) gives the probability of creating an excitation with momentum k and energy ω. For a Fermi liquid:A(k,ω)=Zk δ(ω−εk∗)A(k, \omega) = Z_k\, \delta(\omega - \varepsilon_k^*) + incoherent background, where ZkZ_k is the quasiparticle weight.

Fermi liquid theory (Landau): despite interactions, the low-energy excitations of a metallic system are quasiparticles — dressed electrons with renormalized mass m* and finite lifetime τ∝(ε−εF)−2\tau \propto (\varepsilon - \varepsilon_F)^{-2}. This justifies band theory for metals. Fails when: Mott insulator (strong U), non-Fermi liquids (1D Luttinger liquid, strange metal in cuprates, heavy fermions).

Example MB.1 — RPA Screening and the Plasmon

In the random phase approximation (RPA), compute the dielectric function ε(q,ω)\varepsilon(q, \omega) for the electron gas. Find the plasmon dispersion.

Bare polarization:Lindhard function: ∏0(q,ω)=2∑k(fk−fk+q)/(ω−εk+q+εk+iη)\prod_{0}(q, \omega) = 2\sum_{k} (f_{k} - f_{k+q})/(\omega - \varepsilon_{k+q} + \varepsilon_{k} + i\eta). Atq→0,ω→0:∏0→−N(0)At q\to 0, \omega\to 0: \prod_{0} \to -N(0) (density of states at EFE_{F}). Atq→0At q\to 0, finite ω:∏0→+neq2/(mω2)\omega: \prod_{0} \to +n_{e} q^{2}/(m\omega^{2}) (dynamical limit).
RPA dielectric function:ε(q,ω)=1−Vq∏0(q,ω)\varepsilon(q,\omega) = 1 - V_{q} \prod_{0}(q,\omega) where Vq=e2/(ε0q2).ε(q,ω)=1+(e2/(ε0q2))N(0)V_{q} = e^{2}/(\varepsilon_{0} q^{2}). \varepsilon(q,\omega) = 1 + (e^{2}/(\varepsilon_{0} q^{2})) N(0) at static long-wavelength → Thomas-Fermi screening: ε=1+qTF2/q2\varepsilon = 1 + q_{TF}^{2}/q^{2} where qTF2=e2N(0)/ε0q_{TF}^{2} = e^{2} N(0)/\varepsilon_{0}.
Plasmon:Poles of GscreenedG_{\text{screened}} at ε(q,ω)=0\varepsilon(q,\omega) = 0. Atq→0:ε(q,ω)=1−ωp2/ω2At q\to 0: \varepsilon(q,\omega) = 1 - \omega_{p}^{2}/\omega^{2} where ωp2=nee2/(ε0m)\omega_{p}^{2} = n_{e} e^{2}/(\varepsilon_{0} m). Plasmon frequency: ω=ωp\omega = \omega_{p} (independent of q at long wavelength). For metals: ωp 10eV(UV\omega_{p} ~ 10 eV (UV plasma edge — why metals reflect below ωp\omega_{p} and transmit above for ω>ωp\omega > \omega_{p}). Dispersion at small q:ω=ωp+(3vF2/(10ωp))q2+O(q4)q: \omega = \omega_{p} + (3v_{F}^{2}/(10\omega_{p}))q^{2} + O(q^{4}). The plasmon is a gapped collective mode (Goldstone if long-range forces were absent).
Screening length:Screened potential: Vscr=Vq/ε(q)→V(r)=(e2/r)e−qTFrV_{\text{scr}} = V_{q}/\varepsilon(q) \to V(r) = (e^{2}/r) e^{-q_{TF} r} (Yukawa). Thomas-Fermi screening length: λTF=1/qTF\lambda_{TF} = 1/q_{TF}. ForCu:ne=8.4×1028m−3,N(0)=(3/2)n/EF≈1.13×1047J−1m−3.λTF≈0.55A˚—For Cu: n_{e} = 8.4\times 10^{28} m^{-3}, N(0) = (3/2)n/E_{F} \approx 1.13\times 10^{47} J^{-1}m^{-3}. \lambda_{TF} \approx 0.55 Å — very short screening in metals.

MB.4 Diagrammatic Perturbation Theory

The self-energy and correlation functions can be expanded in Feynman diagrams. At the Hartree-Fock level: ΣHF=Σdirect+Σexchange\Sigma_{\text{HF}} = \Sigma_{\text{direct}} + \Sigma_{\text{exchange}}. Beyond HF: the GW approximation Σ=iGW\Sigma = iGW (W = screened Coulomb interaction from RPA) is the standard first-principles method for band gaps in semiconductors.

Linked-cluster theorem: only connected diagrams contribute to extensive quantities (free energy, self-energy). Unlinked (vacuum bubble) diagrams cancel between numerator and denominator in perturbation theory — this is what makes many-body perturbation theory tractable.

Quantum Monte Carlo (QMC): stochastic evaluation of the many-body path integral. Variational MC (VMC): optimize a trial wavefunction (Jastrow factor × Slater determinant). Diffusion MC (DMC): project to ground state via e−τHe^{-\tau H}. Sign problem for fermions (cancellations between ± signs) is the fundamental bottleneck. Fixed-node approximation: constrain to same nodal surface as trial function.

MB.5 Correlated Phases

Mott insulator → superfluid transition (Bose-Hubbard model in optical lattice): at integer filling, for U/t>5.83zU/t > 5.83z: Mott lobes in the phase diagram. Jaksch et al. (1998) predicted; Greiner et al. (2002) observed with ultracold bosons in an optical lattice — quantum phase transition at T = 0.

Fractional quantum Hall effect (FQHE): at ν = 1/3 (and other fractions), the ground state is the Laughlin wavefunction Ψ=∏i<j(zi−zj)me−∑k∣zk∣2/4ℓ2\Psi = \prod_{i<j} (z_i - z_j)^m e^{-\sum_k |z_k|^2/4\ell^2}(m = 3 for ν=1/3). Excitations carry fractional charge e/3 and obey fractional statistics (anyons). Topological order — no local order parameter.

High-TcT_c superconductors: cuprates (La₂CuO₄ doped with Sr) have TcT_c up to 138 K. Undoped: Mott insulator (half-filled Cu 3d band, strong U). Doped: d-wave superconductivity (gap Δk=Δ0(cos⁡kx−cos⁡ky)\Delta_k = \Delta_0(\cos k_x - \cos k_y)), pseudogap phase, strange metal. Not fully explained.

Definition MB.2 — Common Traps
  • Mean field replaces interactions with averages: it can miss correlations and fluctuations.
  • Quasiparticles are emergent excitations: they are not always bare particles.
  • Green's functions encode response: poles, residues, and spectral weight all matter.
  • Strong coupling often needs new methods: weak perturbation can fail qualitatively.
Exercises — MB.1–MB.5 Many-Body Physics
1.
Write the electron-electron Coulomb interaction in second-quantized form. Identify the Hartree and Fock (exchange) contributions and give their physical interpretations.
eV
Straightforward
2.
Derive the Thomas-Fermi screening length from the static Lindhard function at long wavelengths. What are Friedel oscillations and why do they have wavevector 2kF2k_{F}?
Å
Intermediate
3.Explain quasiparticle weight ZkZ_{k} and the Fermi liquid lifetime τ∝(ε−εF)−2\tau \propto (\varepsilon-\varepsilon_{F})^{-2}. How does ARPES measure the spectral function, and what signals a non-Fermi liquid?
Intermediate
4.Write down the Laughlin wavefunction for filling ν=1/m\nu = 1/m. Show it describes fractional charge e/m quasiparticles using the plasma analogy. What is the energy gap?
Challenging
Key Takeaways
  • Fermion operators: ckck′†+ck′†ck=δkk′c_{k} c^\dagger_{k'} + c^\dagger_{k'} c_{k} = \delta_{kk'} (anticommutators). (c†)2=0c^\dagger)^{2} = 0 encodes Pauli exclusion.
  • HF theory: Slater determinant ansatz. Hartree (direct Coulomb) + Fock (exchange). Misses correlations.
  • Hubbard model: kinetic t vs on-site U. U/t ≫ 1 → Mott insulator. Half-filling + large U → antiferromagnetism.
  • Self-energy ∑(k,ω)\sum(k,\omega): Dyson eqG=G0+G0∑Geq G = G_{0} + G_{0} \sum G. Fermi liquid: sharp quasiparticle, lifetime ~ (ε−εF)−2\varepsilon-\varepsilon_{F})^{-2}.
  • RPA plasmon: collective oscillation at ωp=ne2/(ε0m)\omega_{p} = \sqrt{ne^{2}/(\varepsilon_{0}m)}. Thomas-Fermi screening λTF=1/qTF\lambda_{TF} = 1/q_{TF}.
  • FQHE Laughlin state ν=1/m\nu = 1/m: fractional charge e/m, anyonic statistics. Topological — no local order parameter.