Magnetism arises from spin — quantum mechanical angular momentum with no classical analog. From ferromagnetism to frustrated magnets to quantum spin liquids, magnetic materials display a rich variety of quantum phases driven by exchange interactions.
PrerequisitesSolid-state physics (Ch. SS) · Statistical mechanics (Ch. S) · Quantum mechanics (Ch. 22) · Group theory (Ch. GT)
Learning Goals
Derive the Brillouin function and Curie law for a paramagnet and identify when saturation occurs.
Explain the origin of the exchange interaction and use mean-field theory to compute the Curie temperature TC.
Derive the magnon dispersion ωk∝k2 for a Heisenberg ferromagnet and predict the Bloch T3/2 heat capacity.
Distinguish ferromagnetic, antiferromagnetic, and frustrated geometries and explain how frustration produces spin liquids.
Apply Larmor precession to describe NMR signal generation and spatial encoding in MRI.
MG.1 Paramagnetism and Diamagnetism
In an external field H, a free spin-J atom acquires energy −gJμBmJH. The partition function Z=∑egJμBmJH/kBT gives the magnetization:
M=NgJμBJBJ(x)where x=kBTgJμBJH and BJ is the Brillouin function(MG.1)
At high T (x ≪ 1): M≈NgJ2μB2J(J+1)H/(3kBT) — Curie law: χ = C/T. At low T (x ≫ 1): M→NgJμBJ (saturation).
Diamagnetism: all materials are weakly diamagnetic. The orbital response of closed shells to H gives χdia=−Ze2⟨r2⟩/(6mec2) per atom (Langevin). Negative susceptibility: induced magnetization opposes applied field. Superconductors are perfect diamagnets (Meissner effect): χ = −1.
MG.2 Exchange Interaction and the Heisenberg Model
Magnetism in solids comes from the exchange interaction — a purely quantum mechanical effect arising from the overlap of wavefunctions and the Pauli exclusion principle. For two electrons on adjacent atoms:
J > 0: ferromagnetic exchange (parallel spins lower energy — triplet state preferred). J < 0: antiferromagnetic exchange (antiparallel spins — singlet preferred). Exchange integral: J=⟨↑↓∣1/r12∣↑↓⟩−⟨↑↓∣1/r12∣↓↑⟩ (direct vs exchange term).
The full Heisenberg model on a lattice:H=−J∑ijSi⋅Sj−gμBH∑iSiz. For J > 0: ferromagnet. For J < 0: antiferromagnet. The Ising model (1D solvable): H=−J∑iσiσi+1.
MG.3 Ferromagnetism — Mean-Field Theory
In mean-field theory, replace Sj⋅Si→⟨Sj⟩⋅Si=mSiz (Weiss molecular field approximation). Each spin sees an effective field Heff=H+λm whereλ=2zJ/(gμB)2 is the Weiss constant (z = coordination number).
TC=3kB2zJJ(J+1)(Curie-Weiss temperature, mean field)(MG.3)
Below TC: spontaneous magnetization m ≠ 0. Near TC: m∝(TC−T)β with mean-field β = 1/2. Actual 3D Ising: β ≈ 0.326 (fluctuations matter). Curie-Weiss law above TC:χ=C/(T−TC).
Example MG.1 — Iron Ferromagnetism — Curie Temperature
Iron has TC=1043K, spin S=1,g≈2.2,BCC lattice (z=8). Estimate J from mean-field theory and compare to the actual exchange energy.
Mean-field:TC=2zJS(S+1)/(3kB). With S=1,z=8:TC=2×8×J×2/(3×1.38×10−23).
Solve for J:J=3kBTC/(2zS(S+1))=3×1.38×10−23×1043/(2×8×1×2)=4.31×10−20/32=1.35×10−21J=0.0084 eV.
Compare:This is the effective exchange per bond. The actual 3d exchange in Fe is ~100 meV — 10× larger. Mean-field overestimates TC by including all fluctuations as if they all point in the mean-field direction. Actual quantum Monte Carlo gives correct TC with proper treatment of fluctuations.
Spin waves:The low-T excitations of a ferromagnet are magnons — collective spin-wave modes with dispersion ωk∝k2 (quadratic, unlike phonons which are linear). Magnon contribution to heat capacity: CV∝T3/2 (Bloch T3/2 law).
MG.4 Antiferromagnetism and Frustration
For J < 0 on a bipartite lattice (two sublattices A and B), the ground state has spins on A pointing up and B pointing down — antiferromagnetism. Néel temperature TN=2z∣J∣S(S+1)/(3kB) (same formula as TC). Neutron scattering (magnetic Bragg peaks) detects the antiferromagnetic order.
Geometric frustration: on a triangular or kagome lattice, you cannot simultaneously satisfy all antiferromagnetic bonds. For three spins on a triangle: two can be antiparallel but the third cannot be antiparallel to both. This frustration prevents conventional magnetic order and can give rise to:
Spin liquid: highly entangled state with no long-range order even at T = 0. Ground state is a superposition of many configurations (resonating valence bonds, proposed by Anderson in 1973 and applied to high-Tc superconductors in 1987). Characterized by fractional excitations (spinons) and topological order. Candidate materials: herbertsmithite (ZnCu₃(OH)₆Cl₂), RVB models of cuprate superconductors.
MG.5 Spin Dynamics and NMR
A spin in a magnetic field H precesses (Larmor precession):
For protons: γ = 2.675×10⁸ rad/(s·T) → Larmor frequency νL=γH/(2π). At H = 3 T (clinical MRI): νL=127 MHz (RF range).
NMR (Nuclear Magnetic Resonance): RF pulse at νL tips the magnetization. Relaxation times T₁ (longitudinal, spin-lattice) and T₂ (transverse, spin-spin) encode local chemical environment. MRI adds a gradient field to encode spatial position in the Larmor frequency: frequency encodes location. Fourier transform of FID (free induction decay) → image. Nobel Prizes: Bloch & Purcell 1952, Lauterbur & Mansfield 2003.
Definition MG.1 — Common Traps
Magnetization is material response: it is not the same quantity as applied H or total B.
Exchange is quantum mechanical: ferromagnetism is not caused by classical dipole alignment alone.
Domains reduce magnetic energy: a demagnetized sample can still have ordered domains.
Curie temperature marks collective order: above it, thermal disorder destroys spontaneous magnetization.
Exercises — MG.1–MG.5 Magnetism
1.
Gadolinium (Gd3+,J=7/2,g=2)hasTC=292K. Use the Curie-Weiss law to estimate the exchange integral J for az=12 lattice. What is the Curie constant?
eV
Straightforward
2.Derive the magnon dispersion ωk∝k2 for a Heisenberg ferromagnet and show that the low-temperature heat capacity is C∝T3/2.
Intermediate
3.
Explain the physics of MRI. How does spatial encoding work? Why does SNR scale as H02? What is achievable resolution at 3 T?
Hz
Intermediate
4.Describe the Kitaev honeycomb model and its exact solution via Majorana fermions. Why is this a quantum spin liquid and what physical materials realize it?
Challenging
Key Takeaways
Paramagnetism: M=NgμBJBJ(x). Curie law χ=C/T at high T. Saturation at low T.