Modern Physics · Advanced Topics

Magnetism in Condensed Matter

Magnetism arises from spin — quantum mechanical angular momentum with no classical analog. From ferromagnetism to frustrated magnets to quantum spin liquids, magnetic materials display a rich variety of quantum phases driven by exchange interactions.

PrerequisitesSolid-state physics (Ch. SS) · Statistical mechanics (Ch. S) · Quantum mechanics (Ch. 22) · Group theory (Ch. GT)
Learning Goals
  • Derive the Brillouin function and Curie law for a paramagnet and identify when saturation occurs.
  • Explain the origin of the exchange interaction and use mean-field theory to compute the Curie temperature TCT_{C}.
  • Derive the magnon dispersion ωk∝k2\omega_{k} \propto k^{2} for a Heisenberg ferromagnet and predict the Bloch T3/2T^{3/2} heat capacity.
  • Distinguish ferromagnetic, antiferromagnetic, and frustrated geometries and explain how frustration produces spin liquids.
  • Apply Larmor precession to describe NMR signal generation and spatial encoding in MRI.

MG.1 Paramagnetism and Diamagnetism

In an external field H, a free spin-J atom acquires energy −gJμBmJH-g_J \mu_B m_J H. The partition function Z=∑egJμBmJH/kBTZ = \sum e^{g_J \mu_B m_J H/k_B T} gives the magnetization:

M=NgJμBJ BJ(x)where x=gJμBJHkBT and BJ is the Brillouin functionM = N g_J \mu_B J\, B_J(x) \qquad \text{where } x = \frac{g_J \mu_B J H}{k_B T} \text{ and } B_J \text{ is the Brillouin function}(MG.1)

At high T (x ≪ 1): M≈NgJ2μB2J(J+1)H/(3kBT)M \approx N g_J^2 \mu_B^2 J(J+1) H/(3k_B T) — Curie law: χ = C/T. At low T (x ≫ 1): M→NgJμBJM \to N g_J \mu_B J (saturation).

Diamagnetism: all materials are weakly diamagnetic. The orbital response of closed shells to H gives χdia=−Ze2⟨r2⟩/(6mec2)\chi_{\text{dia}} = -Ze^2\langle r^2\rangle/(6m_e c^2) per atom (Langevin). Negative susceptibility: induced magnetization opposes applied field. Superconductors are perfect diamagnets (Meissner effect): χ = −1.

MG.2 Exchange Interaction and the Heisenberg Model

Magnetism in solids comes from the exchange interaction — a purely quantum mechanical effect arising from the overlap of wavefunctions and the Pauli exclusion principle. For two electrons on adjacent atoms:

Hex=−2J S1⋅S2(Heisenberg exchange Hamiltonian)H_{\text{ex}} = -2J\, \mathbf{S}_1 \cdot \mathbf{S}_2 \qquad \text{(Heisenberg exchange Hamiltonian)}(MG.2)

J > 0: ferromagnetic exchange (parallel spins lower energy — triplet state preferred). J < 0: antiferromagnetic exchange (antiparallel spins — singlet preferred). Exchange integral: J=⟨↑↓∣1/r12∣↑↓⟩−⟨↑↓∣1/r12∣↓↑⟩J = \langle\uparrow\downarrow|1/r_{12}|\uparrow\downarrow\rangle - \langle\uparrow\downarrow|1/r_{12}|\downarrow\uparrow\rangle (direct vs exchange term).

The full Heisenberg model on a lattice:H=−J∑ijSi⋅Sj−gμBH∑iSizH = -J\sum_{ij} \mathbf{S}_i \cdot \mathbf{S}_j - g\mu_B H \sum_i S_i^z. For J > 0: ferromagnet. For J < 0: antiferromagnet. The Ising model (1D solvable): H=−J∑iσiσi+1H = -J\sum_i \sigma_i \sigma_{i+1}.

MG.3 Ferromagnetism — Mean-Field Theory

In mean-field theory, replace Sj⋅Si→⟨Sj⟩⋅Si=mSiz\mathbf{S}_j \cdot \mathbf{S}_i \to \langle \mathbf{S}_j\rangle \cdot \mathbf{S}_i = m S_i^z (Weiss molecular field approximation). Each spin sees an effective field Heff=H+λmH_{\text{eff}} = H + \lambda m whereλ=2zJ/(gμB)2\lambda = 2zJ/(g\mu_B)^2 is the Weiss constant (z = coordination number).

Self-consistency equation: m=BJ ⁣(gμBJHeff/kBT)m = B_J\!\left(g\mu_B J H_{\text{eff}}/k_B T\right). Curie temperature: TC=2zJ J(J+1)/(3kB)T_C = 2zJ\, J(J+1)/(3k_B) (for J → 1/2 Ising: TC=zJ/(2kB)T_C = zJ/(2k_B)).

TC=2zJ J(J+1)3kB(Curie-Weiss temperature, mean field)T_C = \frac{2zJ\, J(J+1)}{3k_B} \qquad \text{(Curie-Weiss temperature, mean field)}(MG.3)

Below TCT_C: spontaneous magnetization m ≠ 0. Near TCT_C: m∝(TC−T)βm \propto (T_C - T)^\beta with mean-field β = 1/2. Actual 3D Ising: β ≈ 0.326 (fluctuations matter). Curie-Weiss law above TCT_C:χ=C/(T−TC)\chi = C/(T - T_C).

Example MG.1 — Iron Ferromagnetism — Curie Temperature

Iron has TC=1043KT_{C} = 1043 K, spin S=1,g≈2.2,BCCS = 1, g \approx 2.2, BCC lattice (z=8z = 8). Estimate J from mean-field theory and compare to the actual exchange energy.

Mean-field:TC=2zJS(S+1)/(3kB)T_{C} = 2zJ S(S+1)/(3k_{B}). With S=1,z=8:TC=2×8×J×2/(3×1.38×10−23)S=1, z=8: T_{C} = 2\times 8\times J\times 2/(3\times 1.38\times 10^{-23}).
Solve for J:J=3kBTC/(2zS(S+1))=3×1.38×10−23×1043/(2×8×1×2)=4.31×10−20/32=1.35×10−21J=0J = 3k_{B} T_{C}/(2zS(S+1)) = 3\times 1.38\times 10^{-23}\times 1043/(2\times 8\times 1\times 2) = 4.31\times 10^{-20}/32 = 1.35\times 10^{-21} J = 0.0084 eV.
Compare:This is the effective exchange per bond. The actual 3d exchange in Fe is ~100 meV — 10× larger. Mean-field overestimates TCT_{C} by including all fluctuations as if they all point in the mean-field direction. Actual quantum Monte Carlo gives correct TCT_{C} with proper treatment of fluctuations.
Spin waves:The low-T excitations of a ferromagnet are magnons — collective spin-wave modes with dispersion ωk∝k2\omega_{k} \propto k^{2} (quadratic, unlike phonons which are linear). Magnon contribution to heat capacity: CV∝T3/2C_{V} \propto T^{3/2} (Bloch T3/2T^{3/2} law).

MG.4 Antiferromagnetism and Frustration

For J < 0 on a bipartite lattice (two sublattices A and B), the ground state has spins on A pointing up and B pointing down — antiferromagnetism. Néel temperature TN=2z∣J∣S(S+1)/(3kB)T_N = 2z|J|S(S+1)/(3k_B) (same formula as TCT_C). Neutron scattering (magnetic Bragg peaks) detects the antiferromagnetic order.

Geometric frustration: on a triangular or kagome lattice, you cannot simultaneously satisfy all antiferromagnetic bonds. For three spins on a triangle: two can be antiparallel but the third cannot be antiparallel to both. This frustration prevents conventional magnetic order and can give rise to:

Spin liquid: highly entangled state with no long-range order even at T = 0. Ground state is a superposition of many configurations (resonating valence bonds, proposed by Anderson in 1973 and applied to high-TcT_c superconductors in 1987). Characterized by fractional excitations (spinons) and topological order. Candidate materials: herbertsmithite (ZnCu₃(OH)₆Cl₂), RVB models of cuprate superconductors.

MG.5 Spin Dynamics and NMR

A spin in a magnetic field H precesses (Larmor precession):

dSdt=γ S×H(Larmor precession, γ=gyromagnetic ratio)\frac{d\mathbf{S}}{dt} = \gamma\, \mathbf{S} \times \mathbf{H} \qquad \text{(Larmor precession, } \gamma = \text{gyromagnetic ratio)}(MG.4)

For protons: γ = 2.675×10⁸ rad/(s·T) → Larmor frequency νL=γH/(2π)\nu_L = \gamma H/(2\pi). At H = 3 T (clinical MRI): νL=127\nu_L = 127 MHz (RF range).

NMR (Nuclear Magnetic Resonance): RF pulse at νL\nu_L tips the magnetization. Relaxation times T₁ (longitudinal, spin-lattice) and T₂ (transverse, spin-spin) encode local chemical environment. MRI adds a gradient field to encode spatial position in the Larmor frequency: frequency encodes location. Fourier transform of FID (free induction decay) → image. Nobel Prizes: Bloch & Purcell 1952, Lauterbur & Mansfield 2003.

Definition MG.1 — Common Traps
  • Magnetization is material response: it is not the same quantity as applied H or total B.
  • Exchange is quantum mechanical: ferromagnetism is not caused by classical dipole alignment alone.
  • Domains reduce magnetic energy: a demagnetized sample can still have ordered domains.
  • Curie temperature marks collective order: above it, thermal disorder destroys spontaneous magnetization.
Exercises — MG.1–MG.5 Magnetism
1.
Gadolinium (Gd3+,J=7/2,g=2)hasTC=292KGd^{3+}, J = 7/2, g = 2) has T_{C} = 292 K. Use the Curie-Weiss law to estimate the exchange integral J for az=12a z = 12 lattice. What is the Curie constant?
eV
Straightforward
2.Derive the magnon dispersion ωk∝k2\omega_{k} \propto k^{2} for a Heisenberg ferromagnet and show that the low-temperature heat capacity is C∝T3/2C \propto T^{3/2}.
Intermediate
3.
Explain the physics of MRI. How does spatial encoding work? Why does SNR scale as H02H_{0}^{2}? What is achievable resolution at 3 T?
Hz
Intermediate
4.Describe the Kitaev honeycomb model and its exact solution via Majorana fermions. Why is this a quantum spin liquid and what physical materials realize it?
Challenging
Key Takeaways
  • Paramagnetism: M=NgμBJBJ(x)M = N g\mu_{B} J B_{J}(x). Curie law χ=C/T\chi = C/T at high T. Saturation at low T.
  • Exchange interaction J: J>0 ferromagnet, J<0 antiferromagnet. From wavefunction overlap + Pauli.
  • Curie temperature: TC=2zJS(S+1)/(3kB)T_{C} = 2zJS(S+1)/(3k_{B}) from mean field. Curie-Weiss: χ=C/(T−TC)\chi = C/(T-T_{C}).
  • Magnon dispersion: ω∝k2\omega \propto k^{2} (ferromagnet). Low-T heat capacity C∝T3/2C \propto T^{3/2} (Bloch).
  • Frustration (triangular/kagome): prevents long-range order → quantum spin liquid, fractional excitations.
  • Larmor precession: dS/dt=γS×HdS/dt = \gamma S\times H. NMR/MRI uses ωL=γH\omega_{L} = \gamma H to probe matter.